Selkirk Ampec Epic VS Onix Graphite Z5 | PICKLEBALL GEAR UP

Choosing the right pickleball paddle can make a big difference in your performance—whether you’re a beginner or pro. This detailed comparison highlights two top contenders: the 2021 FiberFlex X5 and the classic 2018 Nomex Graphite. Read on to explore their specifications, pros and cons, and what type of player each paddle suits best.

Year	2021 | 2018
Skill Level	Beginner to Pro | Beginner to Intermediate
Pros	Excellent control and precision on dinks and volleys Great speed for quick net exchanges High spin potential with FiberFlex surface Well-balanced weight distribution for effortless swings Strong impact power without sacrificing accuracy Long-lasting durability with advanced materials Trusted by tournament players
Cons	On the expensive side compared to mid-range paddles Handle may feel fragile over time for power players Reports of dead spots after extended use Heavier build might not suit smaller players Neck area prone to stress damage Average in shock absorption despite premium pricing Lightweight design may reduce feel on off-center hits

Core	X5 Polymer Honeycomb | Nomex Honeycomb
Surface	FiberFlex (Fiberglass) | Graphite
Medium Weight	7.9–8.4 oz | 7.9 oz (224g)
Light Weight	7.3–7.8 oz | N/A
Edge Guard	Low-profile vinyl edge trim | ¼″ overlapping paddle face

Paddle Length	15 ¾″ | 15 ½″ (394mm)
Paddle Width	8″ | 8 1/8″ (203mm)
Core Thickness	9/16″ | 9/16″ (14mm)

Grip Length	5 ¼″ | 5″
Grip Style	Perforated Cushion | Perforated Cushion
Grip Circumference	4″ (Thin) to 4 ¼″ (Medium) — actual sizes may vary up to ⅛″ | 4 ¼″ (Medium) — actual sizes may vary

Detailed Breakdown: FiberFlex vs. Graphite Paddles

Power & Performance

The 2021 paddle uses Selkirk’s X5 Polymer core, offering enhanced shock absorption and better control during dinks and resets. It’s ideal for players who demand consistency and softness on impact. In contrast, the 2018 model with a Nomex core provides extra pop and is great for fast, attacking players—though less forgiving in mishits.

Surface Material Matters

The FiberFlex surface on the newer paddle delivers excellent spin and textured control, making it perfect for advanced players experimenting with slice or topspin. Meanwhile, the Graphite face of the older model promotes lightning-fast reactions with a crisp, responsive hit—best for flat shots and speed lovers.

Weight Class & Feel

With weights ranging between 7.3 to 8.4 oz, the 2021 model offers flexible customization. Lighter builds aid speed and wrist maneuverability, while heavier options improve stability. The 2018 model holds steady at 7.9 oz—middle ground for players who like a balance of power and control without having to choose.

Who Should Choose Which?

• Go with the 2021 FiberFlex X5 if you want precision, control, and versatility with excellent spin and soft touch.
• Stick with the 2018 Graphite Nomex if you’re a flat hitter who values fast reaction time and prefers a punchy, aggressive style.

“Switching from Nomex to FiberFlex helped me improve my resets and reduced wrist strain during long rallies.”
– Recreational Pickleball Player, Austin TX

Conclusion: Which Paddle is Best?

Both paddles offer impressive performance, but cater to different play styles. The 2021 model provides more control, advanced materials, and balanced play—perfect for evolving players or seasoned pros. The 2018 model, while older, still stands tall with its raw power and excellent speed for aggressive players.

Looking for value and finesse? The FiberFlex wins. Crave old-school speed and pop? Graphite Nomex might still be your favorite.